#1 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Crossing National
Christian school (nondenominational) · Grades 9–12
630 students
Elkhart, IN
BOverall grade630 students12 students per teacher
2026 lists
Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
The private schools in Elkhart County, IN with the most students. Top 31 of 31 schools.
#2 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Bethany Christian Schools
Mennonite school · Grades 1–12
316 students
Goshen, IN
B+Overall grade316 students12 students per teacher
#3 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Trinity Lutheran School
Lutheran (Missouri Synod) school · Grades Pre-K–8
279 students
Elkhart, IN
BOverall grade279 students13 students per teacher
#4 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic School
Diocesan school · Grades K–8
250 students
Elkhart, IN
A+Overall grade250 students10 students per teacher
#5 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Clinton Christian School
Christian school (nondenominational) · Grades K–12
230 students
Goshen, IN
B-Overall grade230 students12 students per teacher
#6 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
St. Vincent De Paul Elementary School
Diocesan school · Grades Pre-K–8
177 students
Elkhart, IN
B+Overall grade177 students14 students per teacher
#7 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
St. John the Evangelist Catholic School
Diocesan school · Grades Pre-K–6
124 students
Goshen, IN
A+Overall grade124 students12 students per teacher
#8 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
United Christian School
Mennonite school · Grades K–12
99 students
Nappanee, IN
BOverall grade99 students14 students per teacher
#9 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Woodlawn Christian School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–11
76 students
Goshen, IN
B+Overall grade76 students10 students per teacher
#10 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Bashor Alternative School
Methodist school · Grades K–12
72 students
Goshen, IN
A+Overall grade72 students6 students per teacher
#11 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Forest Grove School
Amish school · Grades 1–8
46 students
Middlebury, IN
46 students15 students per teacher
#12 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Powerline School
Amish school · Grades 1–8
39 students
Middlebury, IN
39 students13 students per teacher
#13 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Clinton Center Amish
Amish school · Grades 1–8
39 students
Goshen, IN
39 students10 students per teacher
#14 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Old Order Mennonite Garden Spot
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
38 students
Wakarusa, IN
B+Overall grade38 students19 students per teacher
#15 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Pine View
Amish school · Grades 1–8
38 students
Wakarusa, IN
38 students19 students per teacher
#16 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Hillside Mennonite W
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
38 students
Goshen, IN
B+Overall grade38 students19 students per teacher
#17 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Weldy Amish School
Amish school · Grades 1–8
37 students
Nappanee, IN
37 students12 students per teacher
#18 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Hillside Amish School
Amish school · Grades 1–8
36 students
Goshen, IN
36 students12 students per teacher
#19 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Peaceful Woods
Amish school · Grades 1–8
36 students
Syracuse, IN
36 students18 students per teacher
#20 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Pumpkinvine School
Amish school · Grades 1–8
33 students
Middlebury, IN
33 students11 students per teacher
#21 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Cornerstone Christian Montessori School
Montessori school · Grades Pre-K–6
32 students
Elkhart, IN
A-Overall grade32 students6 students per teacher
#22 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Country Echos
Amish school · Grades 1–8
31 students
Nappanee, IN
31 students10 students per teacher
#23 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Wabash School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
31 students
Wakarusa, IN
B+Overall grade31 students16 students per teacher
#24 Largest Private Schools in Elkhart County, IN
Plainview Amish School
Amish school · Grades 1–8
31 students
Middlebury, IN
31 students10 students per teacher
From official public records, updated October 2026.