Benton Mennonite School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
Penn Yan, NY
2532 Baldwin Rd, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Overall grade: B+
ChooseAPrivateSchool.com grade, from official facts compared with similar schools.
- BClass size
- B+Years serving families
What stands out
- One of 10 Christian schools in Penn Yan
In Penn Yan, New York, Benton Mennonite School is a Mennonite private school for students from 1st grade through 8th grade. About 23 students attend, with roughly 12 students per teacher. The school day runs about 7 hours, 180 days a year.
At a glance
- Grades
- Grades 1–8
- Students
- 23
- Teachers
- 2 (full-time equivalent)
- Students per teacher
- 11.5
- Boys and girls
- Coed · 17 girls, 6 boys
- Religious affiliation
- Mennonite
- School day
- About 7 hours
- School year
- 180 days
Reviews
Be the first to share what you love about Benton Mennonite School.
How it compares
- A smaller school: fewer students than 77% of Christian elementary schools in New York.
- Compared with 81 Christian elementary schools in New York.
Students by survey year
Total students reported in official records since 2011–12.
Students by grade
Student body
Questions to ask on a tour
- What is tuition, and what does it include (books, fees, uniforms, trips)?
- Do you offer financial aid, sibling discounts or payment plans?
- Do you accept ESA, voucher or tax-credit scholarship funds?
- How big are classes in my child's grade?
- What support is there for students who need extra help or more challenge?
- Is the school accredited, and by whom?
- What do a typical day and a typical week look like?
- How does the school communicate with families?
Questions about Benton Mennonite School
What grades does Benton Mennonite School serve?
Benton Mennonite School serves grades 1–8.
How many students attend Benton Mennonite School?
About 23 students, with 12 students per teacher, according to official records.
How much is tuition at Benton Mennonite School?
Call the school to ask about tuition, financial aid and payment plans.
Official record · Updated October 2026 · Official search · Something wrong? Tell us
Other private schools nearby
Sunny Haven Mennonite School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
Serving families in Penn Yan since at least 2011
Penn Yan, NY1.0 mi
Emmanuel Baptist Academy
Baptist school · Grades K–12
The smallest classes of any Christian school in Penn Yan
Penn Yan, NY2.5 mi
Valley View School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
One of 10 Christian schools in Penn Yan
Penn Yan, NY2.8 mi
West Wood Mennonite School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
The only all-girls school in Penn Yan
Penn Yan, NY2.8 mi
St. Michaels Elementary School
Diocesan school · Grades Pre-K–5
The only Catholic school in Penn Yan
Penn Yan, NY2.9 mi
Pine Grove Mennonite School
Mennonite school · Grades 1–8
Serving families in Penn Yan since at least 2011
Penn Yan, NY3.9 mi